Agenda item
Formal Business of Council - Allocation to Seats and Appointments to the Executive, Committees and Other Bodies 2009/2010
To receive a report which asks Council to:
a) Appoint the Executive Leader, Deputy Leader and members of the Executive and Shadow Executive for the Municipal Year 2009/2010 and approve their portfolios (Annex A);
b) Agree arrangements for the distribution of places on Member bodies associated with the City of York Council, in accordance with Section 15 of the Local Government and Housing Act 1989 (Annex B);
c) Appoint the Chairs, Vice-Chairs and membership of the Council’s Committees, Boards and other Member bodies, including any partnership arrangements and representatives on Outside Bodies, for the Municipal Year 2009/2010 (Annex C).
Minutes:
Cllr Waller moved, and Cllr Scott seconded, the appointment of an Executive, Leader and Executive Members, together with the allocation of, and nomination to, places on Committees, partnerships and outside bodies, as set out in Annexes B and C to Item 5 on the Council agenda and the amendments sheet circulated around the Council Chamber.*
Nominations to Executive and Shadow Executive
The Lord Mayor then announced that two options had been received for nominations to the Executive and Shadow Executive in addition to those nominations received for Committees, partnerships and outside bodies set out in the annexes to item 5 and the amendments sheet. Option 1 comprised a Liberal Democrat Executive and a Labour Shadow Executive, while Option 2 comprised a Labour Executive and a Liberal Democrat Shadow Executive.
A named vote was taken on each of these options, as follows:
For Option 1 |
For Option 2 |
Abstained |
Cllr Aspden |
Cllr Alexander |
Cllr D’Agorne |
Clllr Ayre |
Cllr Blanchard |
Cllr Taylor |
Cllr Brooks |
Cllr Bowgett |
Cllr Galvin (Lord Mayor) |
Cllr Firth |
Cllr Cregan |
|
Cllr Sue Galloway |
Cllr Crisp |
|
Cllr Steve Galloway |
Cllr Douglas |
|
Cllr Gillies |
Cllr Fraser |
|
Cllr Healey |
Cllr Funnell |
|
Cllr Hogg |
Cllr Gunnell |
|
Cllr Holvey |
Cllr Horton |
|
Cllr Hudson |
Cllr King |
|
Cllr Hyman |
Cllr Looker |
|
Cllr Kirk |
Cllr Pierce |
|
Cllr Moore |
Cllr Potter |
|
Cllr Morley |
Cllr Scott |
|
Cllr Orrell |
Cllr Simpson-Laing |
|
Cllr Reid |
Cllr B Watson |
|
Cllr Runciman |
|
|
Cllr Sunderland |
|
|
Cllr Vassie |
|
|
Cllr Waller |
|
|
Cllr R Watson |
|
|
Cllr Watt |
|
|
Cllr Waudby |
|
|
Cllr Wiseman |
|
|
25 |
17 |
3 |
Option 1 was accordingly declared CARRIED by 25 votes to 17.
Nominations for Cycling Champion
The Lord Mayor then announced that three alternative options had been received in respect of the nominations for the Cycling Champion.
A named vote was taken on the first of these options, namely a job-share arrangement between Cllr D’Agorne and Cllr Merrett, as follows:
For |
Against |
Abstained |
Cllr Alexander |
Cllr Aspden |
Cllr Galvin (Lord Mayor) |
Cllr Blanchard |
Clllr Ayre |
|
Cllr Bowgett |
Cllr Brooks |
|
Cllr Cregan |
Cllr Firth |
|
Cllr Crisp |
Cllr Sue Galloway |
|
Cllr D’Agorne |
Cllr Steve Galloway |
|
Cllr Douglas |
Cllr Gillies |
|
Cllr Fraser |
Cllr Healey |
|
Cllr Funnell |
Cllr Hogg |
|
Cllr Gunnell |
Cllr Holvey |
|
Cllr Horton |
Cllr Hudson |
|
Cllr King |
Cllr Hyman |
|
Cllr Looker |
Cllr Kirk |
|
Cllr Pierce |
Cllr Moore |
|
Cllr Potter |
Cllr Morley |
|
Cllr Scott |
Cllr Orrell |
|
Cllr Simpson-Laing |
Cllr Reid |
|
Cllr Taylor |
Cllr Runciman |
|
Cllr B Watson |
Cllr Sunderland |
|
|
Cllr Vassie |
|
|
Cllr Waller |
|
|
Cllr R Watson |
|
|
Cllr Watt |
|
|
Cllr Waudby |
|
|
Cllr Wiseman |
|
19 |
25 |
1 |
The option for a job-share arrangement was accordingly declared LOST.
A named vote was then taken on the remaining options, namely the appointment of either Cllr D’Agorne or Cllr Merrett as Cycling Champion, as follows:
For Cllr D’Agorne |
For Cllr Merrett |
Abstained |
Cllr Aspden |
Cllr Alexander |
Cllr Galvin (Lord Mayor) |
Clllr Ayre |
Cllr Blanchard |
|
Cllr Brooks |
Cllr Bowgett |
|
Cllr D’Agorne |
Cllr Cregan |
|
Cllr Firth |
Cllr Crisp |
|
Cllr Sue Galloway |
Cllr Douglas |
|
Cllr Steve Galloway |
Cllr Fraser |
|
Cllr Gillies |
Cllr Funnell |
|
Cllr Healey |
Cllr Gunnell |
|
Cllr Hogg |
Cllr Horton |
|
Cllr Holvey |
Cllr Hudson |
|
Cllr Hyman |
Cllr King |
|
Cllr Kirk |
Cllr Looker |
|
Cllr Moore |
Cllr Pierce |
|
Cllr Morley |
Cllr Potter |
|
Cllr Orrell |
Cllr Scott |
|
Cllr Reid |
Cllr Simpson-Laing |
|
Cllr Runciman |
Cllr B Watson |
|
Cllr Sunderland |
|
|
Cllr Taylor |
|
|
Cllr Vassie |
|
|
Cllr Waller |
|
|
Cllr R Watson |
|
|
Cllr Watt |
|
|
Cllr Waudby |
|
|
Cllr Wiseman |
|
|
26 |
18 |
1 |
The option to appoint Cllr D’Agorne as Cycling Champion was therefore declared CARRIED.
Strategic Policy Panel
The Lord Mayor then announced that a proposal had been received to re-establish the Strategic Policy Panel (SPP), for one meeting only, in order to deal with a request for a referral to the SPP of a decision taken by the Executive (Calling In) on 19 May 2009.
A named vote was taken on this proposal, as follows:
For |
Against |
Abstained |
Cllr Alexander |
Cllr Aspden |
Cllr Galvin (Lord Mayor) |
Cllr Blanchard |
Clllr Ayre |
|
Cllr Bowgett |
Cllr Brooks |
|
Cllr Cregan |
Cllr Firth |
|
Cllr Crisp |
Cllr Sue Galloway |
|
Cllr D’Agorne |
Cllr Steve Galloway |
|
Cllr Douglas |
Cllr Gillies |
|
Cllr Fraser |
Cllr Healey |
|
Cllr Funnell |
Cllr Hogg |
|
Cllr Gunnell |
Cllr Holvey |
|
Cllr Horton |
Cllr Hudson |
|
Cllr King |
Cllr Hyman |
|
Cllr Looker |
Cllr Kirk |
|
Cllr Pierce |
Cllr Moore |
|
Cllr Potter |
Cllr Morley |
|
Cllr Scott |
Cllr Orrell |
|
Cllr Simpson-Laing |
Cllr Reid |
|
Cllr Taylor |
Cllr Runciman |
|
Cllr B Watson |
Cllr Sunderland |
|
|
Cllr Vassie |
|
|
Cllr Waller |
|
|
Cllr R Watson |
|
|
Cllr Watt |
|
|
Cllr Waudby |
|
|
Cllr Wiseman |
|
19 |
25 |
1 |
The proposal was accordingly declared LOST and it was
RESOLVED: (i) That the allocation of seats to places for 2009/10 and those nominations to the Executive, Leader, Shadow Executive and remaining Committees, outside bodies etc be approved as set out under Option 1 above.
(ii) That Cllr D’Agorne be appointed as Cycling Champion for the 2009/10 Municipal Year.
(iii) That the Strategic Policy Panel not be re-established.
*Note: Annexes A, B and C to item 5 on the Council agenda, together with the list of amendments, can be found by clicking on the link below:
http://democracy.york.gov.uk/ieListDocuments.asp?CId=331&MId=3914&Ver=4
Supporting documents:
- Report - Allocation to Seats and Appointments, item 12. PDF 40 KB
- Annex A1 - Executive Appointments LD, item 12. PDF 13 KB
- Annex A2 - Shadow Executive Appointments Labour, item 12. PDF 11 KB
- Annex A3 - Executive Appointments Labour, item 12. PDF 14 KB
- Annex A4 - Shadow Executive Appointments LD, item 12. PDF 12 KB
- Annex B - Allocation of Seats, item 12. PDF 27 KB
- Annex C1 - Appointment of Chairs and Vice-Chairs, item 12. PDF 17 KB
- Annex C2 - Appointment to Committees and Other Bodies, item 12. PDF 74 KB
- Annex C3 - Appointment to Outside Bodies, item 12. PDF 71 KB
- Annex C4 - Ward Committee Membership, item 12. PDF 12 KB
- Annex C(i) Recruitment Panel report, item 12. PDF 53 KB
- Annex D - Amendments tabled at Annual Council Meeting, item 12. PDF 24 KB