Issue - meetings
Response to the Recommendations of the Sustainable Street Lighting Scrutiny Board
Meeting: 07/11/2006 - Executive - for meetings from 03/06/00 to 26/04/11 (Item 107)
Response to the Recommendations of the Sustainable Street Lighting Scrutiny Board
This report sets out Officers’ comments in relation to the Scrutiny recommendations presented to the Executive on 25 July 2006, with alternative proposals where appropriate, to ensure that financial controls and reporting procedures are in place to enable the procurement of energy for street lighting to progress without delay.
Decision:
RESOLVED: (i) That the Scrutiny report be welcomed and that the Executive record its appreciation of the work of those Members and Officers involved in the production of the report.
(ii) That the recommendations of the Scrutiny Sub-Committee be agreed, subject to the amendments detailed below:
Recommendations |
Executive Response |
1. Street Lighting Officers discuss and renegotiate the rate charged to the authority for lamp stock electricity supply to minimise financial costs and ensure that the contract to CYC includes upwards of 20% renewable sourcing to be increased towards a target of 100%. |
Agreed, with the following addition: Insert at the end of the recommendation “where the supplier is able to provide renewable sourced energy and subject to the outcome of the forthcoming procurement of energy for street lighting, which will be reported to Members for decision.' |
2. Street Lighting and Finance Officers ensure that the cashable and non cashable energy and financial savings are reported in Gershon Efficiencies responses, ring fenced and invested in increasingly sustainable street lighting stock. |
Not agreed. Re-word as follows: Insert, after “Gershon Efficiencies responses”, “and where feasible reinvest following consideration as part of the annual budget process”. |
3. Street Lighting Officers with the assistance of the Sustainability Officer ensure that CO2 emissions from energy use in street lighting stock are reported annually under EMAS and that targets are set for annual carbon savings. |
Agreed, with the following addition: Insert, at the end of the recommendation: “provided that appropriate resources can be allocated to deliver the savings proposals”.
|
4. Street Lighting Officers should complete the audit and database detailing street lighting stock in line with best practice and the "whole life" details outlined at para 20 as a matter of urgency prior to renegotiating the electricity contract this year. |
Agreed, with the following addition Re-word to: “Street Lighting Officers should use the newly completed and audited inventory detailing the street lighting stock to renegotiate the electricity supply contract this year”. |
5. Upon completion of Audit, Street Lighting Officers should prepare a Street Lighting Strategy for submission to the Executive. |
Agreed, with the following change Remove the words “Upon completion of Audit”. Add: “The Strategy should include a requirement to implement new technology when appropriate”. |
6. Street Lighting Officers should maintain their established contact with pilot authorities trialling Photovoltaic (PV) lighting and other sustainable technologies and endeavour to keep track of the best versions of this technology available. |
Agreed |
7. Street Lighting Officers should recommend the use of PV powered "standalone" systems and other sustainable technologies as the technologies improve and community netted systems installations for areas of the authority without grid netting requiring lighting. Officers should, in this instance, consider whole life costs of installation, including offsetting the installation costs against savings made from electricity billing during the systems life. That the position of using PV and any other advances to sustainable technologies should be included in the annual "Highways Report" |
Agreed |
8. That Sub Committee considering the final report of the former Planning and Transport ... view the full decision text for item 107 |
Minutes:
Members considered a report which set out Officers’ comments in relation to the recommendations of the Sustainable Street Lighting Scrutiny Board, which were presented to the Executive on 25 July 2006.
Comments on each of the Board’s twelve recommendations were set out in paragraphs 5 to 39 of the report. Paragraph 51 presented alternative proposals in relation to recommendations 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 9, with the aim of ensuring that financial controls and reporting procedures were in place to progress the procurement of energy for street lighting without delay.
Councillor Vassie commented on the Board’s recommendations as Energy Champion, expressing support in particular for Recommendation 2.
RESOLVED: (i) That the Scrutiny report be welcomed and that the Executive record its appreciation of the work of those Members and Officers involved in the production of the report.
(ii) That the recommendations of the Scrutiny Sub-Committee be agreed, subject to the amendments detailed below:
Recommendations |
Executive Response |
1. Street Lighting Officers discuss and renegotiate the rate charged to the authority for lamp stock electricity supply to minimise financial costs and ensure that the contract to CYC includes upwards of 20% renewable sourcing to be increased towards a target of 100%. |
Agreed, with the following addition: Insert at the end of the recommendation “where the supplier is able to provide renewable sourced energy and subject to the outcome of the forthcoming procurement of energy for street lighting, which will be reported to Members for decision.' |
2. Street Lighting and Finance Officers ensure that the cashable and non cashable energy and financial savings are reported in Gershon Efficiencies responses, ring fenced and invested in increasingly sustainable street lighting stock. |
Not agreed. Re-word as follows: Insert, after “Gershon Efficiencies responses”, “and where feasible reinvest following consideration as part of the annual budget process”. |
3. Street Lighting Officers with the assistance of the Sustainability Officer ensure that CO2 emissions from energy use in street lighting stock are reported annually under EMAS and that targets are set for annual carbon savings. |
Agreed, with the following addition: Insert, at the end of the recommendation: “provided that appropriate resources can be allocated to deliver the savings proposals”.
|
4. Street Lighting Officers should complete the audit and database detailing street lighting stock in line with best practice and the "whole life" details outlined at para 20 as a matter of urgency prior to renegotiating the electricity contract this year. |
Agreed, with the following addition Re-word to: “Street Lighting Officers should use the newly completed and audited inventory detailing the street lighting stock to renegotiate the electricity supply contract this year”. |
5. Upon completion of Audit, Street Lighting Officers should prepare a Street Lighting Strategy for submission to the Executive. |
Agreed, with the following change Remove the words “Upon completion of Audit”. Add: “The Strategy should include a requirement to implement new technology when appropriate”. |
6. Street Lighting Officers should maintain their established contact with pilot authorities trialling Photovoltaic (PV) lighting and other sustainable technologies and endeavour to keep ... view the full minutes text for item 107 |